I heard that a lot from my American compatriots when I
announced I was moving to Israel. Another common line was “Just don’t get on
any busses!” My husband-to-be (whom I
will refer to as “Z”) assured me that life in Tel Aviv was not scary at all,
and that I would in fact be very safe. I
was 24 years old with a bug for travel (and hearts in my eyes!) and found it very easy to believe him.
So who had the more valid reaction? The Americans, or the native?
So who had the more valid reaction? The Americans, or the native?
The violent and the
tragic fill our TV and computer screens from morning to night. A typical American vision of Israel is of a
chaotic place where rockets and busses explode. This is what they have seen on
the news. And though it may not be on a
daily, or even monthly basis, such things have happened (and still do,
depending on the location).
How accurate was Z’s
feeling of not being in danger? Could this be a sort of blindness from staring
into the sun too long? Or did he just know that in Israel, serious measures had
been put in place to protect him? When Z first visited Washington, D.C. he was nervous.
He eyed the long lines of tourists crowding around the museums (with no security
in sight) and thought, “this doesn’t look good.” When he found out civilians
can carry guns, he was shocked. He actually felt safer in his home town of Tel
Aviv.
But Tel Aviv is known as a bubble. Once inside, the rest of the country’s
troubles seem a million miles away (all the more odd considering Israel’s tiny
size.) I fell under this drowsy sort of
outlook myself. While on a short trip to W.V. in December 2008, a war broke out between Israel and Gaza. Rockets were landing within 20 miles of Tel Aviv. My exasperated
father pointed out that was like someone shooting missiles at us from
Winchester, VA (a town we drove to every day for work.) I admitted that would
be a scary situation. And yet I was not afraid to fly back to Tel Aviv.
For me, it took some getting used to the sight of green-clad
soldiers with rifles slung across their backs munching a falafel pita on the
sidewalk or sitting sleepily on the bus.
And what a pain to have to open my bag every time I entered Dizengof
Center Mall or the Mega Supermarket. But quickly, the oddity of this way of
life faded as an acceptance set in that this was just the reality that kept
things in check. I took the bus to work
every day and the most panic I felt was when a driver tried to explain a fare
change to me in Hebrew.
My conclusion? No, Israel wasn’t as scary as my friends had
imagined. The idea of the total war zone where one risks their life every day
is no more accurate than the picture some conjured that I’d be living in the
middle of the desert riding on a camel.
But their fears shouldn’t be discounted. The volatility of
the region is never far from an Israeli’s mind, even as they get up and go to
work, shop and make dinner. And still I
felt safer strolling in Tel Aviv than I do in D.C., where I’m much more likely
to be mugged. There, I knew someone was looking out as if their life depended
on it.
Hailing from West Virginia, I should have known there is
always more to a place than the stereotypes suggest. But after my foray in
Israel, I sometimes wonder how much of my own ideas about the rest of the world
are skewed?
You remind me ourselves when we moved to the US from Israel. We were shocked how unsafe our neighborhood is (next to one of the top universities!) and that we are not supposed to walk around after 10PM. In Tel Aviv we used to take 3AM strolls, and were never afraid of dark streets.
ReplyDeleteIt's not that bombing is not a real issue - but you are still more likely to lose a loved one in a car accident.
Exactly. And I'd like to find a way to point that out more clearly in the post.
ReplyDeleteFunny thing is, I'm still expecting others to think I'm just saying that and its not true -- even though I was there and they weren't. ;)
This is a great piece, and you made it look like it was fun for you to write. Maybe it was a nightmare to write, but the end result is easy and flowing, and that is the kind of text I prefer reading.
ReplyDeleteI like the way you used the title as a kind of dialogue.
"But Tel Aviv is known as a bubble. Once inside, the rest of the country’s troubles seem a million miles away (all the more odd considering Israel’s tiny size.)"
I would suggest to let it stand as it's own paragraph. It's a strong statement, and you need to give the following story (about you and your dad) some space. Maybe add "drowsy sort of outlook on safety myself." Just to explain which outlook you adopted.
I think the next paragraph needs to start with a clearer separation: You felt safe. Though it did take you some time to get used to the green...
Great post.
-Nigel